.com

Broker commissions by state / Indiana

Benefits broker commissions in Indiana

Employer benefit plans with 100 or more participants that buy insurance report, on Form 5500 Schedule A, what each insurer paid brokers and agents. Across 1,369 Indiana employers' recent filings, insurers disclosed $115 million in broker commissions and fees.

1,369employers on file
1,257,203plan participants
$34,932typical plan's broker pay a year
13.2%typical share of premium

Typical broker pay by plan size

  • Under 100 participants$11,208
  • 100–249 participants$23,317
  • 250–499 participants$43,134
  • 500–999 participants$78,956
  • 1,000–4,999 participants$138,823

Most common insurers

  • The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company293
  • Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company277
  • United of Omaha Life Insurance Company276
  • Delta Dental of Indiana236
  • The Guardian Life Insurance Company of America190
  • Vision Service Plan183
  • Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc.181
  • Metropolitan Life Insurance Company176

When Indiana plans renew

Insurance contracts by renewal month. Renewal is when employers are most open to reviewing their broker.

  1. 3,566Jan
  2. 62Feb
  3. 79Mar
  4. 104Apr
  5. 120May
  6. 92Jun
  7. 214Jul
  8. 98Aug
  9. 93Sep
  10. 168Oct
  11. 66Nov
  12. 52Dec

Broker firms with the most Indiana clients

  • James R. Nelligan & Associates, LLC132
  • Centro Benefits Research LLC101
  • Hylant Group, Inc.94
  • Gibson Insurance Agency, Inc.92
  • MJ Insurance92
  • Watchtower Benefits, LLC67
  • Usi Insurance Services LLC60
  • Apex Benefits Group, Inc.60
  • Gallagher Benefit Services, Inc.60
  • Marsh & Mclennan Agency LLC59

Benefits offered

  • Life insurance1,324
  • Health1,253
  • Dental1,242
  • Vision1,205
  • Long-term disability1,096
  • Temporary disability1,001
  • Other welfare benefits829
  • Death benefits754

Individual agents aren't named here. Figures are what insurers disclosed for each plan's most recent plan year (2024 or later); "typical" is the median. Not legal, tax or investment advice.

Is your company one of them?Search your company for free and see what's on file. The full report shows every insurer, broker and dollar, with how it compares: $99.
Search your company →
Brokers: get Indiana renewals every monthEmployers whose insurance renews in 30–120 days, with the carrier, plan size and the current broker's pay. $149/month for Indiana.
Get the renewal list →

Source: U.S. Department of Labor, EBSA Form 5500 data sets (Schedule A), filings received through September 24, 2026.

Where should we send it?

  1. Pay securely with Stripe (your email carries over).
  2. Your report (or your first renewal file) arrives by email within the hour.
  3. Seat subscribers get a new file on the 1st of each month. Cancel anytime.

By continuing you agree to the Terms of Service and Data Use Policy.