Sample report. Built from a real Texas employer's 2024 Form 5500 filing with the employer's and brokers' identities removed and contract numbers hidden. Your report uses your own filings and shows real names. Find your company →
Benefits broker report · From public Form 5500 filings
Sample Employer, Inc.
Dallas, TX
EIN 00-0000000Plan year 2024DOL data received through Sep 24, 2026Report prepared Nov 6, 2026
1welfare plan with insurance
875participants (start of plan year)
5insurance contracts
2brokers or agents listed
$323,040commissions + fees disclosed
All amounts are what insurers disclosed on Schedule A of your Form 5500 for the plan year shown on each plan — not what anyone is paid today. Form 5500 data arrives with a lag: this report uses each plan's most recent filing in the DOL's public Form 5500 data.
Your plans and insurance contracts
Sample Employer Health and Welfare Plan · Plan 501
Plan year Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024 · Filed Jul 21, 2025
875
participants at start of plan year 1,472 active at year end
HealthLife insuranceDentalVisionTemporary disabilityPrepaid legalLong-term disabilityDeath benefitsOther welfare benefitsFunded through: Insurance, General assets of the sponsor
Commissions + fees disclosed on Schedule A Part I for this plan year
$323,040
LowerMedianHigher
Higher than 90% of plans with 500–999 participants that disclosed broker compensation (median $90,037).
Per participant (start of plan year)
$369.19
LowerMedianHigher
Higher than 84% of plans with 500–999 participants (median $132.88).
Comparison group: 8,302 welfare plans in the same Form 5500 data set with 500–999 participants at the start of the plan year that reported broker commissions or fees on Schedule A. A position on this scale describes where the amount sits, not whether it is appropriate: compensation depends on the coverage bought, premium size, number of carriers and how the broker is paid.
Insurance contracts on Schedule A (5)
Life Insurance Company of North America
LifeShort-term disabilityLong-term disabilityOther (Accidental death and dismemberment, employee assistance prog)
Contract ••• · NAIC 65498 Policy period Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Persons covered1,043
Premium$923,245
Commissions + fees$181,128
Next renewal (projected)Jan 1, 2027
Premium basis: premiums paid to the carrier.
Commissions and fees were 19.62% of premium — higher than 78% of life contracts in the same data set that reported both (median 14.5%).
Broker or agent (as filed)
Location
Commissions
Fees
Fee purpose (as filed)
Broker A Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
$138,487
$15,506
Overrides
Broker A Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
$0
$27,135
Overrides
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company
Dental
Contract ••• · NAIC 65978 Policy period Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Persons covered2,285
Premium$889,603
Commissions + fees$75,733
Next renewal (projected)Jan 1, 2027
Premium basis: premiums paid to the carrier.
Commissions and fees were 8.51% of premium — higher than 38% of dental contracts in the same data set that reported both (median 10%).
Broker or agent (as filed)
Location
Commissions
Fees
Fee purpose (as filed)
Broker A Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
$61,086
$315
Non-monetary compensation, marketing fees
Broker A Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
$0
$9,060
Supplemental compensation
Broker B Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
$5,272
$0
—
Hartford Life and Accident
Other (Accident, critical illness, hospital)
Contract ••• · NAIC 70815 Policy period Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Persons covered504
Premium$194,919
Commissions + fees$43,196
Next renewal (projected)Jan 1, 2027
Premium basis: premiums paid to the carrier.
Commissions and fees were 22.16% of premium — higher than 72% of other contracts in the same data set that reported both (median 17.01%).
Broker or agent (as filed)
Location
Commissions
Fees
Fee purpose (as filed)
Broker A Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
$38,984
$4,212
Bonus
Eyemed Vision Care on Behalf of Fidelity Security Life Insurance Co.
Vision
Contract ••• · NAIC 71870 Policy period Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Persons covered2,039
Premium$140,790
Commissions + fees$12,209
Next renewal (projected)Jan 1, 2027
Premium basis: premiums paid to the carrier.
Commissions and fees were 8.67% of premium — higher than 38% of vision contracts in the same data set that reported both (median 9.98%).
Broker or agent (as filed)
Location
Commissions
Fees
Fee purpose (as filed)
Broker A Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
$12,209
$0
—
Pre-Paid Legal Services Inc DBA Legalshield
Other (Legal)
Contract ••• · NAIC 00000 Policy period Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Persons covered240
Premium$107,740
Commissions + fees$10,774
Next renewal (projected)Jan 1, 2027
Premium basis: premiums paid to the carrier.
Commissions and fees were 10.00% of premium — higher than 16% of other contracts in the same data set that reported both (median 17.01%).
Broker or agent (as filed)
Location
Commissions
Fees
Fee purpose (as filed)
Broker A Agent or broker (not insurance)
Dallas, TX
$10,774
$0
Supplemental compensation
Every broker, agent and other payee listed
Broker or agent (as filed)
Location
Carriers
Contracts
Commissions
Fees
Total
Broker A Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
Life Insurance Company of North America; Metropolitan Life Insurance Company; Hartford Life and Accident; Eyemed Vision Care on Behalf of Fidelity Security Life Insurance Co.; Pre-Paid Legal Services Inc DBA Legalshield
5
$261,540
$56,228
$317,768
Broker B Insurance agent or broker
Dallas, TX
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company
1
$5,272
$0
$5,272
Schedule A Part I lists every insurance agent, broker or other person (for example a third-party administrator) the insurer paid commissions or fees in connection with the contract; the organization type is shown as filed. The same firm can appear under more than one name or office; names are shown exactly as the insurers reported them. Locations are the business address city on the filing.
Renewal calendar
Projected renewal
Carrier
Coverage
Plan
Policy period on the filing
Jan 1, 2027
Life Insurance Company of North America
Life, Short-term disability, Long-term disability, Other (Accidental death and dismemberment, employee assistance prog)
501
Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Jan 1, 2027
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company
Dental
501
Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Jan 1, 2027
Hartford Life and Accident
Other (Accident, critical illness, hospital)
501
Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Jan 1, 2027
Eyemed Vision Care on Behalf of Fidelity Security Life Insurance Co.
Vision
501
Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Jan 1, 2027
Pre-Paid Legal Services Inc DBA Legalshield
Other (Legal)
501
Jan 1, 2024 – Dec 31, 2024
Projected by rolling the policy period on the filing forward to its next anniversary. Confirm the actual date with your carrier or broker; contracts can change dates, be replaced, or end.
What to ask your broker
“Please send your written compensation disclosure.” Since December 27, 2021, brokers and consultants to group health plans who expect $1,000 or more in direct or indirect compensation must disclose it in writing to the plan fiduciary (ERISA section 408(b)(2)(B), added by the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021). Compare it with the amounts above.
“How are you paid on each line of coverage?” A percentage of premium rises when premiums rise; a flat per-employee-per-month amount doesn't. Ask which applies to each contract.
“What else do carriers pay you?” Bonuses, overrides and contingent or incentive payments often show up as “fees” on Schedule A. Ask whether any depend on volume, persistency or growth with a carrier.
“Are you paid anything that isn't on Schedule A?” Fees you pay the broker directly, and payments from TPAs, PBMs or other vendors, may not appear on Schedule A at all.
“Which carriers did you take us to at the last renewal, and what came back?” Ask to see the quotes, including the ones you didn't take.
“Would you work for a flat fee, and what would it be?” Many brokers offer fee-based arrangements with commissions removed or credited back.
“When will we see our renewal, and what's the plan if it comes in high?” Agree on dates now (see the timeline below).
How to read Schedule A
One Schedule A per insurance contract. The insurer fills it in and gives it to the plan; it's filed with the plan's Form 5500. A plan with medical, dental, life and disability coverage from different carriers has several.
Part I lists each broker or agent the insurer paid in connection with that contract during the plan year: commissions, other fees, the purpose of the fees in the insurer's words, and an organization code (for example “insurance agent or broker”).
Part III shows premiums for welfare contracts. For most contracts that's the total premium paid to the carrier; for experience-rated contracts it's earned premium, with claims and the carrier's retention shown separately.
“Persons covered” is the number of people covered by that contract at the end of the policy year, which can differ from the plan's participant count.
Amounts are for the policy year reported, and the policy year doesn't always match the plan year. A contract that started mid-year can show part-year amounts.
To see your filing exactly as submitted, search for your plan in the DOL's EFAST2 Form 5500 search.
Renewal timing
Most group insurance renews once a year on the policy anniversary. A typical schedule, counting back from the renewal date:
150–120 daysAsk for the compensation disclosure. Decide whether to market the plan and what you want to change.
120–90 daysYour broker (or a new one) sends your census and claims data to carriers for quotes.
90–60 daysThe incumbent carrier's renewal and competing quotes arrive. Negotiate.
60–30 daysFinal decisions, contracts, then open enrollment for employees.
Form 5500 for a plan year is due by the last day of the seventh month after the plan year ends (July 31 for calendar-year plans), or October 15 with an extension. That's why public filings lag a year or more behind today.
About this report
This report organizes information from an employer's public Form 5500 filings, as published by the U.S. Department of Labor (EBSA Form 5500 data sets: the Form 5500, Schedule A and Schedule A Part I). We don't change the amounts; we add them up and compare them with other plans in the same data set. Filings that contain obvious entry errors (single amounts over $50 million) are left out of comparisons.
The percentages are positions within a comparison group (“higher than X% of similar-size plans”), not judgments about whether any amount is reasonable. Compensation varies with coverage, premium, plan design, the number of carriers and the services the broker provides. Schedule A doesn't capture every form of broker compensation.
This is information about public filings, not legal, tax, insurance or investment advice, and not an evaluation of any broker, agent or insurer. Talk to your ERISA counsel or benefits adviser before acting on it. Data is provided as is; public filings contain errors and amendments. Verify anything important against your filed return.
Data: U.S. Department of Labor, EBSA Form 5500 data sets (form years 2024 and 2025, “Latest” files received through Sep 24, 2026). Comparison groups: 72,334 welfare plans that disclosed broker compensation.